Is It Time to Overhaul Maryland’s Grounds for Divorce?

ByLindsay Parvis in Family Law, Divorce, Maryland October 22nd, 2019

This blog, the second in a three-part series, (click here for Part 1) looks at other states’ grounds for divorce and how they compare to Maryland, when considering the broader question (discussed in Part 3) about whether it’s time to overhaul Maryland’s grounds for divorce.  Part 1 looks at trends in changes to Maryland’s grounds for divorce over the last several years.  I welcome hearing from readers about their thoughts.

How Other States Approach Grounds for Divorce?

Without comprehensively discussing all states’ laws, there are some notable trends and differences.

Most states’ grounds for divorce fall into the same broad categories as Maryland:

1)      Fault and no fault grounds; and,

2)      Grounds requiring a physical separation and those that do not.

Like Maryland, most states include grounds for incarceration/conviction of a crime, insanity, cruelty/domestic violence, and separation (fault or no fault).

What Do Other States Do Differently?

As for differences, at least 20 states do not recognize adultery as a ground.  Approximately 11 states offer one or very few grounds for divorce, being no fault only divorce states.  And, many states allow “legal separation” as either an alternatively or precursor to divorce.  Among the states allowing separation-based divorce, whether on a fault or no fault basis, separation periods vary from 3 months to 7 years, with an average no fault separation period of 1 to 2 years. 

Grounds permitted by other states of note:

·         Drug and/or alcohol addiction;

·         A breakdown in the marriage, often requiring no separation, having varying titles, such as:

o   Irreconcilable differences;

o   Complete incompatibility;

o   Irretrievable breakdown in the marriage, sometimes requiring failed reconciliations attempts;

·         Impotence;

·         Fraud or fraudulent contract, such as a deception that undermines the essence of the marriage;

·         Pregnancy, if unknown at the time of marriage and by someone other than the spouse;

·         Refusal to financially support a spouse;

·         Varying religious grounds (for example, joining a religious sect disavowing marriage);

·         Bigamy;

·         Deviant sexual behavior, which may include marital rape;

·         Ouster forcing a spouse out of the home and marriage;

·         Gross neglect of legal duties, either to the marriage, a spouse, or child; and,

·         Attempted murder of one’s spouse.

Closing Thoughts

Given the variety of grounds for divorce recognized by other states and developments in Maryland’s grounds for divorce (discussed in Part 1), it is time for Maryland to look at its grounds for divorce, addressing such questions as:

·         Whether to shift away from fault grounds to no fault only grounds?

·         Whether to continue to have fault grounds, and if how expand Maryland’s fault grounds?

·         Whether to further shorten or eliminate separation periods?

·         Whether there is a need for Maryland to offer and recognize “legal separation”?

·         Whether any of Maryland’s grounds are obsolete and should be eliminated?

My next blog in this series ties together Maryland’s trends with other states’ approaches, to consider whether it’s time for a broader update to Maryland’s grounds for divorce and what types of updates.

You can follow Lindsay Parvis for discussion, news, and developments in Maryland family law on LinkedInFacebookInstagramTwitter, and LindsayParvis.com, as well as subscribe to her Newsletter

Lindsay Parvis

Client-focused legal representation starts with listening.  I listen to my clients’ needs, goals, and priorities.  From there, I educate my clients about the law and process to empower them with information and knowledge. This is especially important because my clients often feel unheard and powerless when facing a situation that feels out of control.

 

Contact Lindsay

See more articles by category:

Contact Us

If you have a legal matter you would like to discuss with a JGL attorney, complete the form with your contact information and a brief description of your situation. We will not respond with legal advice, but someone from the firm will contact you to set up a consultation.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.